Back to Blog

Congress Built a State Lane for Stablecoins. Treasury Forgot to Pave It.

Onuora Amobi·November 20, 2026
Regulation
Stablecoins
GENIUS Act
Treasury
State Regulation
Congress Built a State Lane for Stablecoins. Treasury Forgot to Pave It.

On November 17, six US senators signed a two-page letter to Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent. Cynthia Lummis and Kirsten Gillibrand led it. Angela Alsobrooks, Kevin Cramer, Pete Ricketts and Mark Warner signed on. Three Republicans, three Democrats, and one complaint: the rules Treasury wrote to implement the GENIUS Act give federal stablecoin applicants a soft landing and give state-chartered issuers nothing.

The letter itself is unusually blunt for a comment on a proposed rule. It says Treasury's August proposal would let issuers with pending federal applications keep operating under a safe harbor if their regulator grants a waiver, "without a corresponding protection for state issuers." The result, the senators wrote, is that issuers may be pushed toward a federal license, "the opposite of our intent in drafting this legislation."

The people who wrote the law are telling the agency implementing it that it is quietly rewriting it. That is the story.

The GENIUS Act promised issuers a choice between state and federal charters, and the implementation calendar has already made that choice for them.

The statute's design was a dual system, the same one American banking has run on for 160 years. Smaller issuers, those with no more than $10 billion in stablecoins outstanding, could opt for a state regulator if that state's regime is certified as "substantially similar" to the federal one, according to Orrick's summary of Treasury's interim rule. Bigger issuers go federal. Everyone else picks.

That choice only exists if both lanes open at the same time. They won't.

The federal lane has a calendar, a rulebook and a waiting room.

The GENIUS Act takes effect on the earlier of January 18, 2027, or 120 days after regulators finalize their rules. The OCC published its final rule in the Federal Register on October 23, so its 120-day mark falls in February and the January date governs, as Astraea's effective-date breakdown lays out. That is 59 days from today.

The OCC is ready for it. Its final rule, a new 12 C.F.R. part 15, takes effect that same January 18 and includes a waiver safe harbor: an applicant with a substantially complete application pending by that date can get up to 12 months of relief while the agency decides, according to Gibson Dunn's analysis of the OCC framework. Treasury's own proposed rule on issuance, published August 18, builds on that by sheltering pending federal applicants that hold a waiver. A federal applicant knows the forms, the capital floor ($5 million for a new issuer) and the date by which it needs to file.

The state lane has a deadline that lands a year after the law does.

Now look at the other side. Treasury proposed its principles for judging whether a state regime is "substantially similar" back in April. The comment period closed June 2. There is still no final rule, according to Astraea. On September 30, Treasury issued an interim final rule setting out the procedure for state certifications: an attestation, a narrative, the supporting statutes. The Stablecoin Certification Review Committee must vote unanimously within 30 days of a complete submission.

But Treasury is not accepting certifications yet. It will start only after the forms clear Paperwork Reduction Act review, and it says it will post a notice when that happens, per Orrick. Comments on that interim rule are due November 30. Meanwhile, states have until January 18, 2028 to submit their initial certifications. As of early November, no state had been certified, New York included, even though the New York Department of Financial Services proposed its own stablecoin rule in June.

So between January 2027 and whenever the committee gets around to approving a state, a state-supervised issuer is operating under a regime Washington has not blessed, with no safe harbor written down. The senators asked Treasury to cover issuers in states that will have a framework in place before January 18, 2028. The Lummis press release names Wyoming, New York and Nebraska as the states Congress expected to qualify from day one. Treasury has not publicly answered.

The market has already read the calendar.

Nobody has to wait for a final rule to see where the incentive points. Last December the OCC conditionally approved five national trust bank charters for crypto firms. Two were new banks, including Circle's First National Digital Currency Bank and Ripple National Trust Bank. Three were conversions from state trust charters: BitGo, Fidelity Digital Assets and Paxos. Paxos built its stablecoin business under New York supervision. Its approval, as Axios reported, was a move to a national charter that can issue stablecoins under federal oversight.

Those firms had their own reasons. Conversions predate the current rulemaking fight. But they show what a rational compliance team does when one regulator offers a finished rulebook and the other offers a promise. It goes where the rulebook is. Treasury's draft makes that trade more lopsided, not less.

Wyoming is the instructive edge case. The state launched its own Frontier Stable Token in August 2025 and opened it to public purchase in January. Because the issuer is a government, not a business, GENIUS doesn't reach it. The one stablecoin a state controls outright sits outside the law, while the private companies that state wanted to supervise sit in limbo.

Concede Treasury's best argument, and the gap is still a policy choice.

Treasury has a fair case, and it deserves stating. A stablecoin regime is only as strong as its weakest certified state. Waving issuers through on the strength of a state framework that hasn't been reviewed is exactly the regulatory arbitrage critics warned about when GENIUS was being written. The $10 billion cap already limits how much money can sit in the state lane; Forkast noted that the threshold keeps the two largest issuers out of it entirely. And nothing stops a state issuer from applying to the OCC tomorrow. Caution here is not sabotage.

All true. It still doesn't explain the asymmetry. The OCC safe harbor also shelters firms the OCC hasn't approved. A pending application with a waiver is, by definition, an issuer that has not yet cleared review. Treasury is willing to trust a federal application in progress for up to a year. It is not willing to extend the same patience to a state whose statutes have been on the books, in Wyoming's case, since 2019. The senators aren't asking Treasury to skip review. They are asking it to treat "under review" the same way in both lanes.

The cost of not doing that falls on the smaller issuers the state lane was built for. A $200 million issuer chartered in Nebraska cannot spend 2027 guessing whether its regulator will be certified before its banking partners, exchanges and auditors lose their nerve. For that issuer, a federal application isn't a choice between two equivalent systems. It's insurance. Every issuer that buys it shrinks the state lane before a single state has been reviewed, and gives the committee less reason to hurry.

There's a launch-market version of this too. Projects issuing dollar tokens or building payment rails on top of them need to know which regulator will be standing behind the reserve on day one. When the honest answer for state-chartered issuers is "probably fine, eventually," builders pick the issuer with the federal letterhead, and the competitive field narrows to whoever could afford to file in Washington first.

Comments on Treasury's certification rule close in ten days. The law takes effect in 59. If the state safe harbor isn't in the final text by January 18, the dual system Congress wrote will exist on paper, and the issuers will have already voted with their charters.

Share
Back to Blog